Peanut butter is one of my favorite foods. I’m pretty sure I’ve mentioned this before. I also love no-bake pies and tarts, not only because they’re easy, but they’re cold and taste great on summer days. True, it’s not summer quite yet in Australia, but it’s getting there.
Joy The Baker recently combined my fondness of peanut butter and no-bake pies by posting a recipe for a no-bake peanut butter tart on her blog and I was so excited by it that I was the third in line to comment on the post (there are currently 122 comments on that post, proclaiming that this tart looks absolutely delicious!). Shortly after reading the post, I was out buying ingredients.
Living in Australia, I was immediately presented with one major obstacle – the recipe requires graham crackers to make the crust, and graham crackers don’t exist in Australia. I realized I had to either substitute them with something else, or make my own. I took the easy way out and substituted a full 250g package of Arnott’s Nice biscuits, which is a cookie with sugar sprinkled on top. They produce a much finer crumb than graham crackers, but they work just as well.
As you can see, I didn’t use mixed nuts to sprinkle on the tart as Joy did hers; I only used peanuts. The crunch of the nuts was a nice contrast to the tart, which is so creamy.
Unfortunately, or perhaps fortunately, depending on how you look at it, I was the only one in my family to like this tart. My daughter hates peanut butter, and even though my son and husband both like peanut butter, they don’t like cream cheese and my husband said it tasted too much like cream cheese. It’s been 4 days since I made this and there is still a little more than a quarter left – I’m not sure if it’s even still safe to eat!
Years and years ago, I used to make a no-bake peanut butter chocolate pie for family get-togethers in the summer, but I have since lost the recipe. The peanut butter filling in this tart tastes very similar to the peanut butter filling I made for that pie, and I’m tempted to make this again, but omit the whipped topping entirely and spread on a layer of chocolate ganache to see how similar it might taste. What do you think?
That’s enough from me about this no-bake peanut butter tart – head on over to Joy The Baker to get the recipe!
If you enjoyed this recipe, please leave a comment, hit up one of those stars to rate it, and be sure to tag any photos with #sweetestkitchen on Instagram if you made this recipe! I'd love to see what you've created!
I love peanut butter and I think this looks wonderful. I’d have the same situation here though- no one else would eat it but me. Tartlets maybe?
YUM! Peanut butter is truly one of my favourite things. I was actually thinking while I was reading it that it would be perfect with chocolate ganache…Do it!!! And bring it to NZ – I’ll happily help you polish it off 🙂
– B xx
Yum, I adore peanut butter too, this tart looks delicious! I have used Arnotts shredded wheatmeal biscuits in place of graham crackers before, I have never known if that was a good substitute or not!
I love that first picture for some reason! The tart looks delicious. I think I might make it today! Mmm!
That tart looks wonderfully indulgent!
Ohhhhh!! This looks DEEEEELICIOUS!!! I this would make a great addition to my collection of handmade scented charms!
I might even send you one if they turn out 😉
The birthday cake charm turned out great (www.misskittycreations.com) – thanks once again for the inspiration!
Peanut butter is a mainstay in our house and this looks like a delicious way to eat it.
I’m an American in Italy, where peanut butter is scarce and graham crackers are non-existent BUT my mom just sent me some of both. PERFECT TIMING. Can’t wait to make this, thank you 🙂
Hmmmmm i could eat the whole thing.
good heavens! your tart came out absolutely beautiful! LOVE!
Love your photos!
I made Joys pb pie aswell and am the
Only pb-lover in by house… So I ate it myself!
Aren’t her recipes great?!
This looks AMAZING! I have to try it- both ways- whipped topping and chocolate ganache.
this looks AMAZING!! forget summer, I’m making this anytime! Peanut butter is quite possibly my favorite thing on this planet.
YUM!! I like that you just added peanuts 😉
I made this on the weekend, and it was incredible!! very rich, very delicious. We all had second helpings.
What a wonderful looking tart! Id be happy to send some graham crackers your way if you ever wanted some for delicious sweets like this! 🙂
This tart looks so pretty:) and I’m sure it taste just heavenly.Lovely pictures by the way.
Yumm, I think that it looks great and I think adding chocolate to it would make it even better. I love peanut butter and chocolate! You really can’t go wrong with that combo. The pictures are beautiful!
This looks amazing. My daughter would be devastated to find out it has peanut butter in it, as she doesn’t like it either. I might have to make it anyway. Does this make me a bad mother?
Oh, and I tend to use Marie biscuits wherever Graham crackers are called for… they work for cheesecake crusts, anyway!