Adriano Zumbo’s Box Mixes Review

A lot of you may not know who Adriano Zumbo is; he’s a very famous patissier here in Sydney.  He’s been featured on MasterChef Australia where contestants had to bake and prepare his wild desserts, including an outrageous croquembouche, a macaron tower of olive, beetroot and raspberry macarons, and an unbelievable gingerbread house.  You can even buy these things from his shop, but you’ll have be prepared to pay from $105 for the croquembouche and $400 for the macaron tower!

Recently, what Adrian Zumbo has really become famous for is his macarons.  He makes such bizarre flavors that he’s created a Zumbaron craze.  Zumbaron is a combination of his last name, Zumbo, and macaron.  If you live in or near Sydney, you can find these Zumbarons in the brand new Zumbaron trucks – sort of like a food truck, only selling macarons!  I think this is pretty cool and one day I’ll have to get myself into Sydney to stop by one of these Zumbaron vehicles.

Adriano himself looks to be a fun, quirky guy who is a child at heart, but he takes his desserts pretty seriously.  I was surprised to see box mixes with his name on them in my grocery store a couple of weeks ago because this just didn’t seem like something he would do.  At $7.80 per box, I was reluctant to try the macaron mixes, but I snapped up a salted caramel one.  The next time I was at the shop I bought the brownie mix.  I’ll start with a review of the macarons.

I was expecting these macarons to turn out quite well.  Despite having issues with Donna Hay’s macaron box mix, I had higher hopes for Adriano Zumbo’s.  What I absolutely love about Adriano’s mixes is that there is a video available online at every step of the way.  Simply visit his website, or use a QR scanner on your smartphone to scan the QR code that is printed on the box.  The videos are high quality, as well as being clear and easy to understand.  With the macaron mix, it comes with meringue mixture, almond mixture, caramel filling mixture, 2 large piping bags and a cardstock circle template to trace circles on the baking paper.  All you need to add is plain water to the meringue mix, and butter to the caramel filling.

Using Instagram, I documented my time spent making these.  Making macarons is usually quite easy, it’s just the technique and knowing when to stop mixing that makes macarons so tricky.  I watched Adriano’s video of the mixing step a couple of times and felt confident about the way I was doing it.  I piped the mixture onto the circles I had traced and let it set for 10 minutes, as per instructions.  However, I do know that you should be able to touch the macaron batter without having the batter end up on your finger, and after 10 minutes, it was still leaving batter on my finger.  I let the trays set another 20 minutes, then put them in the oven.

Here is where I was going against my gut feeling.  The instructions said to bake the macarons at 160C.  In my experience, that temperature is too high.  However, I still had faith in Adriano’s instructions, so 160C it was.  Within minutes, though, the macarons had risen quickly and the top of each macaron had cracked.  None of the shells developed feet.  Definitely, the oven temperature was too high.  This batch of 24 macaron shells was obviously ruined.  The photo of this batch is in the collage below, bottom left.  I took this batch out a bit too early as well, so they were a little under-baked.

For the next batch of macarons, I lowered the temperature of the oven by 30 degrees and also stuck a wooden spoon in the oven door (something I’ve done previously for macarons).  This batch did better, although I still got some cracked shells.  None of these shells developed feet, either.  The photo of this batch is in the collage below, bottom right.  I also noticed that the macaron shells were very orange, while the photo of the macaron on the box was a light caramel-color.

I tried to think of anything I could have done wrong, other than the oven temperature.  I felt confident that I had mixed the batter properly, though.

I was very disappointed with my shells, but I still prepared the filling and sandwiched the macarons together.  I expected them to taste nice, but I wasn’t even impressed with that either.  The filling tasted more like butter than caramel.  I was expecting these macarons to be so delicious; it was a huge let-down.

I am reluctant to give this box mix a thumbs-down because I do know of people who have had success with it, but it just hasn’t worked for me.  I was thinking I’d give these salted caramel macarons another go a few months down the road, but after tasting them, I think I’ll pass.  I was so disappointed that I didn’t even bother to take photos of them with my real camera!

Now, just to prove to you that I have made macarons before, from-scratch, here are the first ones I ever made – Nutella/coffee macarons, matcha macarons, chocolate/peanut butter macarons, and my favorite were these lemon macarons.  I even made these pistachio macarons that I didn’t end up blogging about, but posted on Flickr.  With the experience I’ve had of Donna Hay’s and Adriano Zumbo’s macaron mixes, I think I’ll just stick with homemade macarons from now on!

You’d probably think that Adriano’s brownie mix turned out just as bad as the macarons, but it was the complete opposite.  I really loved the brownie mix.  I hate to keep comparing Donna Hay and Adriano, but Adriano’s brownies were heaps better than Donna’s.

There are also video instructions for the brownies, but I certainly don’t need to watch instructions to make brownies; this is like second nature to me!  This box comes with the brownie mix, which includes white chocolate chips, and a separate packet for chocolate chunks.  I under-baked these slightly and they were so deliciously and sinfully gooey.  They became quite hard by the next day and I did not like them cold.  I heated up them in the microwave, just until the chocolate was gooey again, and they basically tasted like they were fresh from the oven.  I’d definitely make this box mix again.

I would still recommend giving Adriano’s mixes a go, if you have a spare $7.80 to spend on a gourmet packet mix.  If you’re having trouble deciding between Donna Hay’s and Adriano Zumbo’s, I’d not hesitate in telling you to buy Adriano’s!

If you’ve prepared Adriano’s macaron mix – either the salted caramel or passionfruit, please, leave a comment and let me know how they turned out; I’d love to hear about it!

10 thoughts on “Adriano Zumbo’s Box Mixes Review

  1. Lucy

    No! Nobody needs to resort to a box brownie mix! Especially as you said they were hard the next day and not good cold – two major faults in my opinion! Shame on Zumbo for selling out (cannot blame him though as it is easy money as I can see lots of people buying them). But nearly $8 for substandard results?! Not worth it! Get out your cookery books people or see the other fab recipes on this fab blog!

    Reply
  2. Reny

    I’ve made both Adriano Zumbo’s and Donna’s macaron mixes and I have to say, the salted caramel mix was the worst out of the 3 (his passionfruit ones coming in first, then Donna’s, as they hardly cracked and the taste was great, but I could have done with a circle stencil), I’m not sure what I did wrong :( His passionfruit mix was great, I don’t think any of the shells cracked!
    I’m glad his brownie mix turned out well for you, I’ve tried Donna’s and really enjoyed them, so look forward to trying Adriano’s.

    Reply
  3. Kim

    I’m so glad I came across this review! I have tried both Zumbo’s salted caramel and passionfruit macarons and they were all pretty much fail attempts! The very first time I attempted the salted caramel ones only 6 shells turned out nicely with “feet” the rest of them didn’t have feet and were cracked. Feeling confident that I almost nailed it, I went out and bought another packet which turned out to be a complete disaster! All the shells were cracked and stuck to my baking paper! Feeling extremely discouraged I have finally summoned up the courage to try them again recently. However another pretty much fail attempt….the shells didn’t crack this time, but none of them had “feet”, the batter was oozing out from the side, all the shells stuck to the baking paper! I managed to peel them off leaving barely any sponge underneath the shell. So we pretty much had filling and macaron shells! I have watched the video’s from his website and followed the instructions step by step. I have no idea what I’m doing wrong! If anyone has worked it out… Please let me know! Thanks!

    Reply
  4. Grace

    Hi all. I too have tried the salted caramel mix and found it flavourless. However the new raspberry and chocolate mix taste great. Having said that I am unable to get decent feet and my shells crack. I found the on line video and am disappointed that the resting time is not on the packet mix instructions. I have had two goes at the raspberry ones and feel I got the right consistency in the mix both pre and post almond meal addition. Any help would be appreciated – perhaps it’s asking a bit much of a packet mix.

    Reply
  5. Bridget

    I had exactly the same result with choc-raspberry variety Zumbo also has! Not a single one turned out nicely, and I’m a somewhat seasoned macaron-maker myself! I’m surprised there was no time set aside for drying the macarons before baking them either – I never omit the drying stage when making them from scratch.
    Homemade all the way!

    Reply
  6. Deb

    Macarons can be very temperamental i just finished baking 2 boxes of each flavor of Zumbo’s macarons and they all turned out perfect I also made pistachio ones from my own recipe and you can’t tell the box ones from the one’s i made from scratch. There’s so many elements that can cause macarons not to turn out , humidity is a big factor i always have the air con going when i bake them in the hotter months and mixing bowl and beaters have to be completely clean, oven has to be at the perfect temp and if the mixture is not mixed enough they will crack. Over the past few years i have made countless batches and by trial and error have worked out the perfect macaron and Zumbo’s box mix do work and taste great if done exactly to directions

    Reply

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>